onference Report on "Peripheral Modernities". II Lisbon Summer School for the Study of Culture
Faculdade de Ciências Humanas, Universidade Católica Portuguesa
MUDE (Fashion and Design Museum), Faculdade de Ciências Humanas/UCP, Maritime Station of Alcântara, Orient Museum, Lisbon, Portugal, July 8 – 15, 2012.
A report by Elizabeth Kovach and Jennifer Ch. Müller
> Conference Outline
Here are some highlights of this very rich program:
Peripheral DiscoursesThe first keynote lecture was held by ROBERTO VECCHI (University of Bologna) on the "Periphery as a Work: Eccentric Modernities and Luso-tropical Rearrangements". Luso-tropicalism, a term introduced by sociologist Gilberto Freyre, refers to the notion that Portugal was a more humane colonizer than other European nations. According to Vecchi, it is epistemologically fake, and his talk negated the notion of a regime of uniqueness. Vecchi’s talk applied theoretical concepts to Brazilian, Portuguese and African cultures as it covered (1) a general framework for considering a peripheral conceptual axis, (2) the notion of multiple dimensions, which entails not merely dealing with the periphery as a form, and (3) an epistemological analysis of the production of peripheries. Addressing the case of Portugal, Vecchi argued for using, or reusing, postcolonial discourse. According to Vecchi, the world works and produces multiple temporalities with the periphery as a multiplied space. Open dimensions of prospects and limits illustrate multiple meanings of the term 'culture'. These meanings are an ideological battlefield. Vecchi described the Portuguese modern periphery as a mixture of competing facts that encompass complex identities of the Atlantic and Europe. Here, Vecchi also addressed what he called the "semiperiphery." The sociological definition of the semiperiphery implies a particular modernity, such as that which occurred at the end of Portuguese colonization in 1975. Modernist techniques began to move to colonized spaces that formed their own, particular modernities. Vecchi also discussed a double colonialism concerning Brazil, which involved the transformation of space at different points in time and different places throughout history: a double re-territorialization, for example, inscribes Africa as a new Brazil. Semantic effects follow, such as the shifting of the general to the particular. This highly insightful, complex talk covered a lot of territory, both theoretical and geographical.
The Modern QuestionIn their master class "Travelling Concepts, Metaphors and Narratives for the Study of Culture: Coming to Terms with Peripheries, Modernities and other Key Concepts", VERA NÜNNING (University of Heidelberg) and ANSGAR NÜNNING (University of Giessen) shared their expertise on the tools of academic discourse. The workshop commenced with a discussion of key questions, including: What happens when concepts, metaphors and narratives travel across (disciplinary and national) boundaries? What is the relationship between concepts, metaphors and narratives in the interdisciplinary contact zone? An introductory lecture then included the presentation of a diagram in which concepts, metaphors and narratives each occupied a corner of a triangle:
Equipped with new insights into the conference’s concepts, participants explored 'the modern question' by attending various paper sessions. These included PhD-candidate LEANOR SÁ's (Catholic University of Lisbon) presentation on "Early Crime Identification Photography (in Portugal): a Mark in Modernity and its Obsessions with Taxonomy, Visual Culture and Surveillance". She discussed the use of photography in indentifying criminals, a practice with a long and fascinating history that began in the 1850s at the Préfecture de Police de Paris. French police officer Alphonse Bertillon used photography to develop an index of physical features that were purportedly tied to criminality. This index was used internationally by the 1890s and exemplified a widespread surveillance of the periphery via an obsession with the visual, taxonomy and social control. From today’s perspective, one can say that these portraits of criminals catalogue marginalized populations. By sharing a wealth of images and historical information about this chapter in modern history, Sá presented an archive of modernity that exposed an anxiety surrounding the modern project.
Peripheral Modernisms and Modern (Con)tensions
Moving from mainstream performing arts to the marginal, ADIEL PORTUGALI (University of Tel Aviv) presented a combination of theoretical thoughts and musical examples related to "Marginal Sounds: The Story of Jazz in China". To illustrate his research, he asked three questions: (1) Why Jazz? (2) Why marginal? (3) Why does it matter? He then illustrated core/periphery dynamics of jazz in China. In the early 1920s, jazz entered the scene in Shanghai with Victor Sasson. In 1976, jazz reappeared in China and has come to be known as 'yellow jazz'. The fundamental qualities of jazz (improvisation, rhythms, no lyrics) are universal. But 'yellow jazz' crosses particular ethno-musical borders and identities. Jazz gets no attention from academia, media or authorities in China. Jazz culture is mainly manifested as anonymous and peripheral. Portugali also explored the idea of landscapes as soundscapes, noting the differences between jazz in Peking and Shanghai.
The highly feminized, commercial imagery shown by Hernandés came into stark contrast with the abstract structures shown by PhD student SANJA HORVATINCIC (University of Zadar) in a talk entitled "The Peculiar Case of Spomeniks. Monumental Commemorative Sculpture in Former Yugoslavia between Invisibility and Popularity". She introduced the term of 'spomenik' as officially known as an "architectural or sculptural work dedicated to the memory of meritorious people and important historical events" built during Tito’s regime. She shared images of spomeniks, which are colossal, other-worldly sculptural forms. She defined them as visualizations of both victims and perpetrators. Horvatincic’s research analyzes contemporary internet and blog commentaries dedicated to spomeniks. She suggests that spomeniks place the position of the power on the periphery, because they are often found in the middle of nowhere, in fields and forests, which makes their appearance often unexpected and disturbing. Horvatincic posits that a lack of public interest, political will and intellectual interest in spomeniks indicates an avoidance of dealing with the former regime.
Claiming the Modern in Multiple Ways
The II Lisbon Summer School provided participants with the opportunity to discuss their research with international peers from a variety of subject backgrounds. Professors were a constant source of productive feedback for the students. Within the inspiring atmosphere of a breathtaking city, the Lisbon Consortium not only offered an impressive academic program but also countless cultural experiences that included a performance by legendary director Robert Wilson, a visit to the spectacular studio of contemporary artist Joana Vasconcelos, a private tour of the Oriental Museum and much more. The conference embodied the disparate, varied nature of modernity and modernism in a variety of ways: in the internationality of participants, in the range of topics covered, in the places participants visited and connections (theoretical and professional) that were made. It was, therefore, highly successful in achieving its aim of addressing, as the call for papers states, "the multiple ways in which the modern has been claimed".
Chair: Isabel Capeloa Gil
Isabel Capeloa Gil (Catholic University of Lisbon): Opening remarks
Roberto Vecchi (University of Bologna): "Periphery as a work: eccentric modernities and luso-tropical rearrangements"
Carles Guerra (Museu d’Art Contemporani de Barcelona): "A place deprived of History and forced to a discontinuous Modernity"
The Modern Question
António Sousa Ribeiro (University of Coimbra): "Excentric modernities: Vienna 1900 reconsidered"
Ansgar Nünning & Vera Nünning (University of Giessen and University of Heidelberg): "Travelling concepts, metaphors and narratives for the study of culture: Coming to terms with peripheries, modernities and other key concepts"
Chair: Jorge Vaz de Carvalho
Ellen Sapega (University of Wisconsin): "Simultaneous contrasts: Literary modernism and visual culture in early twentieth century Portugal"
Paulo de Medeiros (University of Utrecht): "Infinite modernisms"
Chair: José Miguel Sardica
Timothy Simpson (University of Macau): "Glass architecture, fictious capital, and Macau’s enclave urbanism"
Jorge Santos Alves (Catholic University of Lisbon): "A modern hero in the making – Hang Tuah in contemporary Malay literature and cinema"
Xiaomei Chen (University of California): "Staging chinese communist revolution in post socialist China"
Chair: Rita Figueiras
Márcio Seligmann-Silva (Unicamp, São Paulo): "Violence and testimony in modernity: thinking beyond the dichotomy of center and periphery"
Barbie Zelizer (University of Pennsylvania, Annenberg School of Communication): "When the peripheral masks as central: American journalism, modernity and Cold War mindedness"
Chair: Peter Hanenberg
Wolfgang Hallet (University of Giessen): "The invention of the modern western city in graphic fiction"
Elisabeth Bronfen (University of Zurich): "Cleopatra’s cultural survival"
Isabel Capeloa Gil (Catholic University Lisbon): Closing remarks
Modernisms and Modernization
Chairs: Alexandra Lopes, Ansgar Nünning, Lara Duarte
Ana Cachola (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Coming in from the margins: modernisms as congenitally/intrinsically peripheral"
Elizabeth Kovach (University of Giessen): "Modern Misery: Alternatives to American Modernity and Modernism in Tillie Olsen’s Yonnondio: From the Thirties"
Chairs: Alexandra Lopes, Luísa Leal de Faria, António Sousa Ribeiro
Leonor Sá (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Early crime identification photography (in Portugal): a mark in modernity and its obsession with taxonomy, visual culture and surveillance"
Inês Alves Mendes (University of Oxford): "Portuguese first modernism and the visual arts: Peripheral identities"
Marisa Fernándes Falcón (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Occupy the city. Empty spaces for creative minds"
Sofia da Costa Pessoa (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Museums and modernity dynamics: The emergence of the Popular Art Museum"
Chairs: Alexandra Lopes, Isabel Capeloa Gil, Ellen Sapega
Beatriz Puertas Hernández (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Embodying modernities in China since the early twentieth century: the lure of tradition, the lure of progress"
Sanja Horvatincic (University of Zadar): "Spomeniks – Monumental commemorative sculpture in former Yogoslavia between invisibility and popularity"
Jennifer Ch. Müller (University of Giessen): "The Bologna-process between German tradition and transnational modernity"
Daniela Agostinho (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Transmodernity and (de-)colonial gaze in Raquel Schefer’s Nshajo (The Game) and Filipa César’s The Embassy"
Chairs: Alexandra Lopes, Marília Lopes, Márcio Seligmann-Silva
Sónia Pereira (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Living on the edge: Black metal and the refusal of modernity"
Bart Vanspauwen (Lisbon University): "Beyond post-colonialism. Lusophone musical reconnections of young cultural entrepreneurs through the web"
Miguel Pedro Quadrio (Catholic University of Lisbon): "O lugar (poli)sistémico da crítica journalística des artes performativas"
Gaspare Trapani (Catholic University of Lisbon) "Cristo si è fermato a Eboli de Carlo Levi e a denúncia de uma 'outra Itália'"
The Modern Meaning of Peripheral
Chairs: Peter Hanenberg, Roberto Vecchi, Isabel Capeloa Gil
Paula Inés Laguarda (University of Argentina): "Modernity, urban cultures and popular sectors in a marginal space of Argentina (La Pampa, 1882-1951)"
Luca Salvi (University of Bologna): "The hidden form: Petrarch and the Hispanic-American (Post-)Modernism"
Claudia Breitbarth (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Traveling as a longing for the periphery. On the example of some works of Raoul Schrott"
Ana Salgueiro Rodrigues (Catholic Universiy of Lisbon): "The strange case of the 'five wandering artists', Madeira, 1916: a peripheral modernity strikes back Modernity"
Chairs: Peter Hanenberg, Vera Nünning, Jorge Santos Alves
Cristina Graça (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Tango, periphery and modernity"
Anabela Leandro dos Santos (Catholic University of Lisbon): "'When a chicken becomes a duck by the hand of a quack'. Two case studies: the representation of the body in Demétrio Cinatti’s Autoplastia and in Lam Qua’s paintings"
Amélia Cruz (Catholic University of Lisbon): "In which sense does modern youth literature debate the conflicts(s) between center and periphery?"
Elena Brugioni (University of Minho): "Contemporary African writing, and critical paradigms. Narrating with the Indian Ocean"
Chairs: Peter Hanenberg, Wolfgang Hallet, Adriana Martins
Ana do Carmo (Catholic University of Lisbon): "The flight and expulsion of the Germans at the end of the IIWW – a challenge for postmodern museology"
Elsa Alves (Catholic University of Lisbon): "The Zone and the Globe: Spatial Modes in Nuclear Time"
Glaura Cordoso (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Acácio Videira’s iconographic archive and the Cinema"
Joana Mayer (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Peripheral modernities at the centre of cultural programmes: the exhibition 'Borders' at the Gulbenkian Foundation in Lisbon"
Chairs: Peter Hanenberg, Xiaomei Chen, Timothy Simpson
Tânia Ganito (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Rebellious yawns, disenchanted laughter: Cynical realism and China’s post-revolutionary modernity"
Adiel Portugali (Tel-Aviv University): "Marginal sounds: The story of jazz in China"
Maria Ana Carneiro (Catholic University of Lisbon): "Carmarate in the media: Peripheral cultural memory"
Catarina Duff Burnay (Catholic University of Lisbon): "The flows of Portuguese television fiction: production models, platforms, international sales"
An evening with Robert Wilson: "1. Have you been here before? 2. No, this is the first time."
Welcome reception sponsored by Lisbon City Hall
Teatro São Luiz – Faust Fantasia by Peter Stein
FLAD – Lecture and Talk with Gonçalo M. Tavares
Maritime Stations – Visit to Almada Negreiros’ panels
Artist’s studio – Visit to Joana Vasconcelos’ studio
CAL – Photography exhibition and talk with the artist
Orient Museum – Visit to the Orient Museum
Doca de Alcântara – Lisbon Sightseeing Boat Tour and IILSSC Closing Dinner
© bei den Autor_innen und bei KULT_online
Fotos: Elizabeth Kovach und Jennifer Ch. Müller