Conference Report on "The Arts of Mediation"
Catholic University of Lisbon, 17-19 March 2010
After welcoming and introductory words by ISABEL CAPELOA GIL, the conference opened with a keynote lecture by RICHARD GRUSIN, co-author with Jay David Bolter of the seminal work Remediation: Understanding New Media (1999). The lecture, titled "Premediation, Affect and the Anticipation of Security", addressed questions of mediation and premediation in the context of contemporary social networks, new media and the present socio-political conditions of global insecurity. Grusin stressed that all mediation starts with the body – and even the other way round – and took a look at, among other things, how the contemporary human body, in working with interactive social networks on mobile phones or home computers, performs gestures which are anticipatory of connectivity. In the way it referred to the sense of insecurity which pervades our age, the lecture raised a number of insights that would recur throughout the three-day conference: the challenges of new media and technological innovations, the mediation of local and global memory, and mediation in the face of national trauma.
Reflections on the problematic nature of (re)mediation of national identity and memory were equally present in ELSA PERALTA’s paper "Mediating the Past: Empire and Public Memory", and in CÂNDIDA CANDAVEZ’s paper "Mediation in Tourism – The Importance of Being Naïve", on the mediation of national identity during the Salazar age in Portugal. In Candavez’s paper, the construction of a people’s singularity is, in part, enacted through the touristic branding of a nation and with the help of the tourist’s gaze. The mediation of travelling was also discussed in KAI SICK’s lecture on two travelogues of North Pole explorations at the beginning of the 20th century. Alongside the dichotomies of distance and proximity, singularity and continuity, authenticity and technicity, he examined the characteristics of the travelogue as mediation strategy.
The complex mediation of powerful images pertaining to a nation’s icons or stereotypes was also touched upon in the lecture on the movie Queen Christina, presented by ELIZABETH WÅGHÄLL NIVRE at the PhDnet Round Table, under the title "Reenacting the Past: Queen Christina of Sweden in the Movies". The potential of media and movie images to either fight and challenge or, on the other hand, perpetuate certain ideas, both positive and negative, about racial or national identity, was further illustrated by FRANK STERN’s lecture on the Jewish gaze throughout 20th century movies, titled "The Jewish Gaze from the Screen".
The (re)mediation of national memory and trauma carries certain responsibilities, as was illustrated in ELENA AGAZZI’s lecture on Günter Grass’s Camera Obscura. Günter Grass’s was not the only case of a complex (re)mediation of national past analysed during the conference. Recent evolutions in China, as well as the modernisation put violently in motion with Mao’s cultural revolution, were seen through the looking-glass of movies in TANIA GANITO’s paper "Remediation, memory and identity in Zhang Yang’s film sunflower" and with the help of photographs in ELISABETTA COLLA’s paper "Picturing the Hunger: The Barthesian Punctum in the Photograph 'Mao and the farmers'".
The keynote by DAVID WELLBERRY, "Kafka’s Wish: On the Art of Interpretation" took on the feel of an excursion. His close reading of Kafka’s text "Wunsch, Indianer zu werden" illustrated the mediation of images from visual arts to literature, philosophy, and back, at the same time scrutinising the very notion of interpretation as such.
The central function of narrative as a tool for structuring catastrophes, and the importance in this process of selection, abstraction and prioritisation, was illustrated in ANSGAR NÜNNING’s and VERA NÜNNING’s paper entitled "How Do You Turn Catastrophe into Art? – Metafictional Reflections on the Impact of Pre- and Remediation on the Representation of Reality in Julian Barnes’s A History of the World in 10½ Chapters".
The dramatically different mediation of global and local memories in news channels was the subject of BARBIE ZELIZER’s keynote lecture "Where Local Memories Go in the Global Flow of News". Since local memory and global media(tion) work in significantly different ways, there is often no real match between them, particularly after trauma. As a case study, Zelizer used the collapse of communism in Hungary in 1989, questioning the problematic way memory travels as news in global media.
The panel "Meaning(s) and Mediation" took a closer look at both technical and cultural aspects of mediation, discussing among other things why some functions of the mobile phone medium are successful and others are not, and how this determines premediation (CARLA GANITO: "The Mobile Phone as a Technology of Premediation"), and examining digital visual archives as a source of meaning making and change in the discourse of 'media art' (FLORIAN WIENCEK: "Mediating Media Art – Digital Visual Archives as Mediation-Tools"). The influence of media and the importance of intermediality were further explored in lectures by ISABEL SIMÕES FERREIRA ("The Celebration of the Wedding of Prince Charles to Camilla Parker Bowles: Royal Mediation and Press Mediatization") and ANA CHRISTINA MENDES ("'In CinemaScope and Glorious Technicolor': Film as Mediation in Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses"). SABRINA KUSCHE’s lecture "New Media(tion): cultural models of reality in the new literary genre e-mail novel" introduced the new genre of e-mail novel as a representation of new models of reality, and stressed the impact of new narrative forms on culture.
All told, the conference revealed the many ways of mediation with which we are confronted in everyday cultural life: from journalism, to Facebook, to literature, film and art, mediation is inevitably present, creating our knowledge and memory as well as our 'immediate' reality. Different media and technologies, and the mediatised narrations they convey, are utterly crucial in shaping our means and strategies of meaning making.
Richard Grusin (Wayne State U.): "Premediation, Affect and the Antecipation of Security"
Frank Stern (U. Vienna): "The Jewish Gaze from the Screen: From Molly Picon to Daniel Craig and Melanie Laurent"
David Wellberry (U. Chicago): "Kafka's Wish. On the Art of Interpretation."
Barbie Zelizer (Annenberg School – U. Penn): "Where Local Memories Go in the Global Flow of News"
Ansgar Nünning (GCSC – U. Giessen) & Vera Nünning (U. Heidelberg): "'How Do You Turn Catastrophe Into Art?' Metafictional Reflections on the Impact of Pre- and Remediation on the Representation of Reality in Julian Barne's A History of the World in 10 ½ Chapters"
Michael Schudson (U. Columbia): "News as a Blurred Genre: The Contemporary Transformation of Journalism"
PhDnet Round Table, Chair: Peter Hanenberg (FCH – CECC)
Elizabeth Wåghäll Nivre (U. Stockholm): "Reenacting the Past: Queen Christina of Sweden in the Movies"
Elena Agazzi (U. Bergamo): "Günter Grass Camera Obscura: The Shadows of Memory and the Horizons of Desire"
Uwe Wirth (U. Giessen): "Scenes of Remediation"
Panel Meaning(s) and Mediation, Chair: Fernando Ilharco (FCH - CECC)
Carla Ganito (FCH – CECC): "The Mobile Phone as a Technology of Premediation"
Martin Zierold (GCSC – U. Giessen): "Making Meaning of Mediations in Change from 'Techno-Images' to the 'Next Society': Analysing Theories of Meaning Making and Media Change"
Florian Wincek (Jacobs U. Bremen): "Mediating Media Art – Digital Visual Archives as Mediation Tools"
Panel Remediation(s) of Nationhood, Chair: Catarina Burnay (FCH – CECC) and Teresa Ferreira (FCH – CECC)
Bernadette Kneidinger (U. Vienna): "The (Re-)Mediation of National Identity in the Sports Coverage. A Qualitative Analysis of Swiss and Austrian Newspapers about the EURO 2008"
Anna Rettberg (GCSC – Giessen, PhDnet member): "The Remediation of a 'Rebranded Englishness' in Contemporary English Literature"
Olivier Nyirubugara (U. Amsterdam): "The Past in a Nutshell: Naming as a Memory Art"
Elsa Peralta (ICS): "Mediating the Past: Empire and Public Memory"
Ana Bela Ramos Morais (FLUL): "Representations of the Hero and of the American Stereotypes in Contemporary Cinema"
Tânia Ganito (ISCPS – CECC): "Remediation, Memory and Identity in Zhang Yang's film Sunflower"
Panel Scenes of Remediation, Chair: Gonçalo Silva (FCH – CECC)
Adriana Martins (FCH – CECC): "Ethical (Re)Mediation in Margarida Cardoso's A Costa dos Murmúrios"
Stefano Rosso (U. Bergamo): "Mediation and Radical Cuts: On Postwestern Revisionism in Fiction, Film and TV Series"
Rui Brás (CECC): "Mediating an Idea of Russia"
Panel The Culture of Immersion, Chair: Carla Ganito (FCH – CECC)
Fernando Ilharco (FCH – CECC): "The Backgroundedness of New Media: Questioning the Conditions of Possibility of Contemporary Daily Life"
Vincenzo Martella (U. Bergamo, PhDnet member): "The Function of Mediation in Adorno's Cultural Theory"
Vanda de Sousa (CECC – FCH): "'Big Brother is Watching You' or TV as the New Technological Home"
Panel Reading Technologies, Chair: Pirjo Lyytikäinen (U. Helsinki)
Angela Locatelli (U. Bergamo): "Hybrid Discourses and the Rethoric of Mediation in Early Modern England"
Sabrina Kusche (GCSC – U. Giessen, PhDnet member): "New Media(tion) – Cultural Models of Reality in the New Literary Genre 'E-mail-Novel'"
Isabel Simões Ferreira (FCSH – UNL): "The Celebration of the Wedding of Prince Charles to Camila Parker Bowles: Royal Mediation and Press Mediatization"
Panel Literature as Mediation, Chair: Alexandra Lopes (FCH – CECC)
Diana Gonçalves (CECC, PhDnet member): "Imaging Literature: Foer's Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close and the Remediation of 9/11"
Ana Cristina Mendes (CEAUL): In CinemaScope and Glorious Technicolor: Film as Mediation in Salman Rushdie's Satanic Verses"
Hanna Mäkelä (U. Helsinki. PhDnet member): "Beyond Rivalry: Mimetic Desire and the Mediation of Art in Siri Hustved's What I loved"
Panel The Social Use of Technology, Chair: Martin Zierold (GCSC – U. Giessen)
Gonçalo Silva (FCH – CECC): "Web 2.0: User Generated Mediation"
Patrícia Dias (FCH –CECC): "The New Media and the Mediation of Corporate Visual Identity: A Portuguese Case Study"
C. Susana Abrantes (UFRJ – Brazil): "African Realities in Construction: Some Notes on Learning Tools, Students, Mediation and Power"
Panel Mediating Conflict, Chair: Kai Sicks (GCSC – U. Giessen)
Maria Emília Fonseca (FLUL): "From Arms to Art: From a Culture of Conflict to a Culture of Peace"
Daniela Agostinzho (CECC): "The Mediation of Memory and Trauma in the Aftermath of the Yugoslav Wars"
Elisabetta Colla (CECC): "Picturing the Hunger: The Barthesian Punctum in the Photograph 'Mao and the Famers'"
Panel Journalism and the Challenges of Mediation, Chair: José Miguel Sardica (FCH – CECC)
Rita Figueiras (FCH – CECC): "The Art of Punditry"
Irmgard Wetzstein (U. Vienna): "The Handling of Political Conflicts in Quality Journalism – Similarities and Differences in the News Coverage of Higher and Lower Escalates Conflict Phases"
Nelson Ribeiro (FCH – CECC): "Radio and the Mediation of News in Portugal during World War II"
Panel Remediating Identity, Chair: Patrícia Dias (FCH – CECC)
Catarina Burnay (FCH – CECC): "RTP Açores Television Fiction. The Mediation of 'Açorianidade'"
Cátia Ferreira (CECC): "Remediated Selves: Having a Second Life Through an Avatar"
Christina Mohr (GCSC – U. Giessen): "No Stories to Live By – On Cultural Premediation in Ron Kovic's Born on the Fourth of July"
Panel Spaces of Mediation, Chair: Uwe Wirth (U. Giessen)
Kai Sicks (GCSC – U. Giessen): "Peary, Cook and the Mediation of North Pole Exploration Around 1900"
Cândida Cadavez (ESHTE): "Mediation in Tourism – The Importance of Being Naïve"
Michele Whiting (Bath Spa U.): "Negotiating Hollow Space"