Conference Report on the 2013 Hermes Consortium Seminar "New Worlds, New Literatures, New Critiques"
University of Wisconsin – Madison, 9th - 14th June 2013
A report by Reinhard M. Möller, Beatrice Seligardi and Polina Shvanyukova
> Conference Outline
Everyone had a first chance to mingle at the Opening Reception, organized the evening before the official start of the Seminar. Throughout the event, the opportunities to get to know each other, both during the Consortium activities and outside working hours, were excellent. By the end of a very intense and stimulating week, the group had become very tight-knit. This became evident by the turnout at the unofficial closing dinner. Parts of the group also used the opportunity to meet in Chicago after the seminar had ended.
TRANSNATIONAL LITERARY TRANSFERS AND PRACTICES OF TRANSLATION
The afternoon panel of the first day of the seminar dealt with heroic figures across times and national contexts. From heroes with impairment in Icelandic sagas (TODD MICHELSON-AMBELANG, UW-Madison) to contemporary Finnish writer Rosa Liksom and her epic heroes (KASIMIR SANDBACKA, Oulu) and back to Baudelaire's Dandy as heroic myrmidon (GEERTJAN DE VUGT, Tilburg), the audience was given the opportunity to trace new trajectories of the heroic in literature and popular imagery.
After such a stimulating start to the seminar, the participants took part in the Library Research Workshop organized by Todd Michelson-Ambelang. Todd gave us a tour around the UW-Madison Library, during which we learned a lot about the history of the university, as well as about the impressive collection of volumes (including very special books in various Asian languages) owned by the library.
LITERARY TRANSGRESSIONS AND GLOBAL LITERARY TRAJECTORIESThe third panel, entitled "Colonial Trajectories," opened the second day of the seminar. Once again, the variety of the national contexts and temporal frameworks discussed was extremely refreshing. REINHARD M. MÖLLER (Giessen) focused on the case of the German-British traveller Georg Forster. In order to explore the systematic links between specific aesthetic conceptions of foreignness, the literary configuration of encounters with Otherness, and the role of literary criticism in the reception of works from other national contexts, Reinhard analysed the articulation of these links throughout Forster's oeuvre. LISANNE SNELDERS (Amsterdam) discussed the case study of the contemporary Dutch academic journal Indische Letteren. She argued that this journal functions as a mnemonic community that actively constructs the cultural memory of the country's colonial past in the Dutch East Indies. TOM GOULD (London) focused on the most recent examples of the travelogue genre. Barthes's Empire of Signs and Baudrillard's America were read by Tom as 'anti-travelogues', by dint of their refusal to accommodate cultural differences within the rigid Eurocentric value system.
CHRISTOPHER McVEY (UW-Madison), BEATRICE SELIGARDI (Giessen), and AMMAR NAJI (UW-Madison) presented their papers in the panel dedicated to Postcoloniality and/in the Novel. Christopher offered an impressive, in-depth, close reading of Michael Ondaatje's Anil's Ghost. He argued that the book eloquently transcends the national peculiarity of historical traumas by, on the one hand, highlighting the limitations of representing the repressed and silenced, and, on the other hand, by offering new and more inclusive concepts of community and citizenship. Zadie Smith's On Beauty was the case study in the analysis of the ever-evolving genre of campus fiction discussed by Beatrice. The scope of the paper was to identify the tendencies that have had major influence on the development of the genre which, since its first hybrid-formulaic configuration in the nineteenth century, has continued to be further hybridized. Ammar talked about contemporary Anglophone Arab writing and its focus on the new migratory understanding of identity, which manifests an original "'diasporic consciousness'" whose evolution takes place in connection with the increased mobility of Arab migrants both in Europe and in the United States.
At the last panel of the day, TOM IDEMA (Nijmegen) focused on the application of notions of "worlding" to literary texts which represent transgressions of the nature/culture or human/animal boundary, using Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars trilogy as a point of reference. The notion of "world literature" can, as the work of theorists like Donna Haraway suggests, be fruitfully applied to the literary construction of alternative 'worlds' as environments that are not exclusively centred around the figure of the human being. LAURA BRU (UW Madison) emphasized the complex strategies by which literary narratives represent movements through cultural spaces in terms of (un)homeliness as an aesthetic as well as a cultural issue: the complex interplay between aspects of familiarity as well as disruption can, as Bru argued with reference to texts by Nadine Gordimer and Latife Tekin, be seen as a literary strategy of worlding which impugns fixed cultural standpoints and ideologies.
DIFFERENT NOTIONS AND FACETS OF WORLD LITERATURE IN DIALOGUE
WORLD LITERATURE, GENDER, PERFORMATIVITY, AND HISTORYThe last two days of our Seminar started on Thursday morning with a panel entitled "Gender, Nation, Body, Politics". This panel engaged with the problematic of World Literature by focusing on how this new critical concept challenges some of the most important topics in Cultural Studies. The first paper was given by KEVIN BOETTCHER (UW-Madison). In his paper, Kevin showed how English authors writing on 17th century colonial Virginia situated themselves as emblematic eaters when presenting the food knowledge offered by the "Indians" to their readers. This "exotic food writing", however, often served to reinforce the European national perception of selfhood. The second panelist, FEMKE ESSINK (University of Amsterdam) drew attention to the relationship between nation and gender. She investigated the critical potential of adaptations by analysing the case of a 1947 novel, Evenings (De avonden), which was transposed first into film and later into a stage play. Femke was especially interested in looking at how the representation of the protagonist's homosexuality has changed according to different cultural influences. The last paper of the morning was given by ALAINYA Kavaloski (UW-Madison). Alainya continued the reflection on national identities by considering how contemporary representations of homelands under conditions of violence are translated between languages, texts, and images.
After lunch, we dedicated the afternoon to some rest from exciting intellectual discussions. The organizers gave us an opportunity to see something completely different and totally unexpected: The House on the Rock. One hour away from Madison, this architectural complex lies in the bucolic and idyllic Wisconsin countryside. However, if the landscape invites the spectator to enjoy the peacefulness of hills and forests, The House on the Rock is something completely different. Designed by Alex Jordan during the second half of the 20th century, this place is a tour de force. The house itself is a reinterpretation of some oriental influences, with a Japanese Garden, and small, dark rooms full of tapestries and exotic furniture. The Infinite Room is composed of a bridge that extends up into the woods that surround the building. But after the proper 'house', the visitor gets a taste of a series of mad collections of all kinds: dollhouses, butterflies, clocks, the reconstruction of a 19th century street, a circus, an orchestra, a series of musical machines, a big whale in a huge room – and these are just a few of the unbelievable things that you can see, and that definitely prove that there is no limit to human imagination (or madness).
Literature and Performance was the title of the very last panel on Friday, and JESSICA GROSS (UW-Madison) began with a paper on graphic novels in which she presented two case-studies: The Rabbits by Shaun Tan and John Marsden, and Déogratias by J.P. Stassen. Her analysis focused on the ways the new worlds are created in violent encounters between cultures. The second presentation shifted to theatre performance. BRUNO HENRIQUES (University of Lisbon) discussed the near-absence of Ibsen and the strong preference for Brecht as a model for the construction of Portuguese modern theatre. The aim of his paper was to show how political dynamics can interfere and shape the reception of culture in a specific society. The Summer School got wrapped up with rap: POLINA SHVANYUKOVA (Giessen) offered a lively presentation about multilingual Italian rap. She demonstrated how new musical genres arise from the interaction between cultural artefacts like American traditional rap and new social dynamics, such as the ever-increasing presence of immigrants in the Italian context.
All in all, the HERMES Seminar 2013 offered a lot of valuable insights and suggestions on world literature as a literary phenomenon as well as a versatile reading method. Fortunately we had the chance to develop them in a fittingly international, transatlantic environment during a highly productive week on the beautiful campus of UW-Madison.
Poetry and Poetic Forms
Chair: Sona Nováková (Charles University, Prague)
Gabrielle Ekman (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "Reading Tennyson in Sierra Leone: The Politics of Poetry in Nineteenth Century Freetown"
Alba Cid Fernández (University of Santiago de Compostela): "The Poem as Essay. A Comparative View in Current Galician and Canadian Poetry"
Marco Paone (University of Santiago de Compostela): "A Transatlantic Perspective on Anthologies in Translation: Italian Poetry between Argentina and Spain"
Transformation of the Heroes and the Heroic
Chair: Karen-Margrethe Simonsen (Aarhus University)
Todd Michelson-Ambelang (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "Othering the Hero: On Inclusion, and Disabling of the Hero with Impairment in the Sagas and Þaettir of Icelanders"
Kasimir Sandbacka (University of Oulu): "Gender, Modernity, and Ironic Reflections of the Epic Hero in Kreisland by Rosa Liksom"
Geertjan de Vugt (Netherlands Research School for Literary Studies, Tilburg): "The Dandy as Heroic Myrmidon: Baudelaire and the Politics of a Lost Harmony"
Chair: Susana Araujo (University of Lisbon)
Reinhard M. Möller (Justus Liebig University Giessen): "New Worlds and New Aesthetics in the Late 18th Century: Alterity, Travel (Writing) and Global Criticism in Georg Forster"
Lisanne Snelders (University of Amsterdam): "New Critique in a New World: Remembering Colonialism in a Multifaceted Mnemonic Journal"
Thomas Gould (University College London): "Theory as Travelogue: Roland Barthes' Empire of Signs and Jean Baudrillard's America"
Postcoloniality and/in the Novel
Chair: Stephan Besser (University of Amsterdam)
Christopher McVey (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "'To give him a name would name the rest': Ethics, History, and Nation in Michael Ondaatje's Anil's Ghost"
Beatrice Seligardi (Justus Liebig University Giessen): "Blurring Boundaries: Genre Hybridization and the Representation of Cultural Hybridity in Zadie Smith's On Beauty"
Ammar Naji (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "The Newness of Diasporic Worldliness and Anglophone Arab Literature"
Space and Spatiality
Chair: Gaston Franssen (University of Amsterdam)
Tom Idema (Radboud University, Nijmegen): "Engaging the Nonhuman: Worlding in Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars Trilogy"
Laura Bru (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "Towards the Limits of Home: Moving Across Contested Spaces Through Literary Narrative"
Gender, Nation, Body Politics
Chair: Beatrice Michaelis (Justus Liebig University Giessen)
Kevin Boettcher (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "'Pampered Bellies': Internalizing the Contact Zone in Early Modern Virginia"
Femke Essink (University of Amsterdam): "Adaptations as Critique: Evenings (De avonden) and the Representation of the Netherlands as a Gay-Tolerant Society"
Alainya Kavaloski (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "Messianic Architectures: Fetishism of Territory and Commodity in Nicole Krauss's Great House"
Literature and Performance
Chair: Heta Pyrhönen (University of Helsinki)
Jessica Gross (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "New Worlds: Violent Intersections in Graphic Novels
Bruno Henriques (University of Lisbon): Ibsen after the Carnation Revolution"
Polina Shvanyukova (Justus Liebig University Giessen): "I was Born Here: Challenging National Identity in Multilingual Italian Rap"
HERMES SYMPOSIUM (Wednesday June 12, 2013)
Djelal Kadir (Penn State University): "Worlding Theory in World Literature"
Chair: Susan Stanford Friedman (University of Wisconsin-Madison)
Caroline Levine (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "New Old New: The Tempos of World Literature"
Chair: Ellen Sapega (University of Wisconsin-Madison)
César Domínguez (University of Santiago de Compostela): "Damaged in Transit? World Literature, World-Literatures, Translation"
Chair: Mario Ortiz-Robles (University of Wisconsin-Madison)
B. Venkat Mani (University of Wisconsin-Madison): "A Pact with Books: Measuring the World with Literature"
Library Research Workshop for Graduate Students
Hermes Symposium Reception and Dinner
Excursion to "House on the Rock" with Dinner
© bei den Autoren und bei KULT_online
Fotos: Beatrice Seligardi